First smart watch recommendations

Hi everyone. I’m looking for recommendations for a smart watch, for my Android phone. I am a carpenter and get fed up with having to constantly stop to the my phone out to respond to messages etc.

I’m looking for a smart watch that isn’t too expensive, or can be picked up second hand for a fair price. My ideal watch would be;

sturdy ( I’ll most likely get a case of sorts), -has the ability to show messages, WhatsApp messages and emails on the screen in their entirety. -able to reply directly from the watch. -changeable straps.

I’m hoping it makes life a bit easier and stops me having to get my phone out.

TIA!

4 Likes

I’m fairly new to this world as well. However, I have learned a couple of things. It seems as though the ability to respond to messages will eliminate a bunch of the $100 or less options. I know samsung Watch will respond. (Using wear os operating system) The xiaomi smart bands and redmi watch use a different system and won’t allow replies.

6 Likes

I love my Zeblaze Stratos 3. I got it off AliExpress for $35 a year ago and it’s been perfect since. Beautiful bright screen, GPS, all kinds of sensors. It has most of the features my wife’s Apple Watch has but for a fraction of the price.

It’s not a recognizable brand but it works well and I won’t be upset when it breaks eventually since it was that cheap.

Got my son a Zeblaze GTS 3 for school for $12 as well.

5 Likes

Note that there is nothing stopping you using a GW (samsung) on a pixel - sure certain health metrics require samsung app/phone (but possible to sideload) but no hardware reason they can’t work.

Its worth noting that if he does get an iPhone then going forward there will be limitations in terms of being able to reply to messages as Apple locks this down to apple watch only.

NFC excluding apple and wear os (android’s mobile operating system) is pretty limited:

Fitbit might be an option as works with android and iPhone and uses google wallet - but they don’t sell in all countries anymore and limited to quick replies on android and no option for replies on iPhone; and personally I think the fitness features are woeful.

Garmin: Gamrin pay is on most garmin’s but they generally aren’t overly supported by a lot of banks in most countries, so you would need to check in your region as to which banks or digital services support it. For example in my country you are limited to 6 banks and 3 digital services - so its was very easy for me to set up a digital service which is direct pass through to my normal credit card so still get my points etc (just like I was using my normal card) - had it set up, agreed and loaded on the watch within 30 mins. The best option for you would be the Venu 3 (or venu 2 plus at a pinch - no full replies on android, but can do it via leveraging phone’s voice assistant) as it can do full replies to texts on android, and or you can leverage the phones voice assistant on android or iPhone to make those replies if wanted. Its a 45mm case with a 1.4inch screen (or can go for the smaller 3s); and being a garmin it has excellent health features, excellent fitness features (compared to smartphones, but only very good when compared to fitness watches), and includes some basic training metrics and analytics like VO2max, Recovery time and workout benefit. Biggest issue is going to be price - not sure you will find it in the range you are prepared to spend! There are cheaper options like the Vivoactive 5 that has nfc an in your range, but like the rest you are limted to quick replies on android and no repiles on iPhone.

Amazfit Balance has NFC but only applicable to Curve - and not sure thats an option for you. Reply is quick on android nothing on iPhone. fitnes features are Ok, and it while it has good training metrics they don’t overly work well as the HR is only good and they are still learning how to apply training metrics so they can be reallly hit and miss. Fitness features are on the good side for a smartwatch but can’t match the fitness brands or what apple can offer if using 3rd party apps.

Huawei watches do offer NFC, but like balance its really restrictive - so you would have to check if even an option in your country. Relpy like the balance is quick on android nothing on iPhone. HR is very good, gps is meh on most of their watches, but the Good HR doesn’t always equate to good health metrics - really hit an miss; some models offer training metrics but again like amazfit - they are based off what garmin does but they don’t have them right yet, so really hit and miss in terms of good training estimations. Fitness features are on the good side for a smartwatch but can’t match the fitness brands or what apple can offer if using 3rd party apps.

Wear os watches - not included here as most are locked to android. Not sure if any are currently able to work with iphone (i know the fossil gen 6 did). However like the rest, while can do full replies on android, locked from doing that on iPhone (if it can connect). Of course has google wallet which is massive bonus. Fitness features in most is pretty woeful comapred to a fitness watch but some of them do have the odd interesting feature i.e. GW watchs including running dynamics (though very basic); the new oneplus watch 2 includes a lot of ball strike metrics for racket sports and might be tempting if racket sports are main focus.

Note: depending on fitness features required - that might swing/determine best option.

Note: NFC isn’t essential if you are generally going to have you watch on it. Might also be worth considering that it may be possibe to get a NFC watch strap or ring - as may be an alt option. Note that most of the watch straps tend to be on the quick release watch strap system so may not be an option for a proprietary watch system like what apple watch or pixel watch 2 uses. I know that garmin (at least for the venu 3) and huawei use this as their main strap system.

4 Likes

I have the Amazfit GTS4. It does not have NFC but otherwise is a decent watch. It has good fitness tracking and also has the ability to load third party apps. The main difference is the apps on the watch are not the same apps as on the iPhone (and probably Android phones too). But, for fitness it’s every bit as good as my wife’s Apple Watch and the battery life is far better.

Another thing about send/receiving texts, I have another smart watch, a Luxium Shield. I don’t think it’s quite as good as the Amazfit, but does have BP measurements and you can send text from the iPhone by utilizing the voice assistant. On the Luxium the VA uses Siri on the iPhone, so when you get a text, you can use VA and have Siri send a text message.

2 Likes

Reply to text messages - means a full smartwatch (some other and fitness watches do canned responses - if that is OK then they will easily give you the +3 day battery life).

Problem is that with full smartwatches you are going to struggle to get +3 day battery life with AOD on. Closest, and more likely only 3 days battery life is Ticwatch Pro series (usage and settings will determine if more than +3 days). If AOD off is ok, then fitbit may be your best optin.

If canned responses are Ok would suggest looking at a Garmin Venu 2 / Vivoatcive 4 or Fenix 6 as these watches have a similar level of smarts (apart from being able to take calls on watch - will push to phone / can only do canned responses / cannot initiate texts/calls); as VA4/F6 will easily give you +5 days.

2 Likes

I just got my smartwatch fitness tracker in and I’m a little disappointed. Is there no text back on these watches because it’s only giving me the option to put them on the trash I would be highly disappointed if I have to return it. All I want is a watch that you can text and call or at least quick replies like my Fitbit versa :confused:

1 Like

I got a Fitbit Versa 3. I love it! I did have a bit of buyers remorse because afterwards the price of the Ticwatch 3 Pro dropped in my country for Black Friday. But I’m still pleased with what I got considering what it cost me.